Wednesday, 27 May 2020

ALTERNATIVE HISTORY OR THE TRUTH?


 "Our dead are always with us. But they are not alive. That's the nature of being dead, and it's best we accept it." 
         - C.K. Stead 'My Name Was Judas'

I listened to the final of the National Programme's recording of C.K. Stead's 'My Name Was Judas' on the radio this morning. I missed most of the series and will try and get it on repeat or podcast. Robert, I'm sure you will find it of interest even if you will be in conflict with a lot of the content.
To me it is excellent. It's a sensible, common sense and likely look at Jesus, his life and his activities that grew in myth through the gospels and have become the mainstay of Christianity.

"And when I heard, two days later that the stone had been rolled away from the mouth of the tomb in the night, and that the body was gone, I knew this must be the work of the Temple priests and the Sanhedrin - or must have been done at their behest. It's one of the ironies of the story, as I look back on it, that this piece of grave robbery by the priesthood, intended to prevent a cult of Jesus growing around the site of his burial had (from their point of view) the worse effect of fostering the much more powerful myth that he had risen from death." 
-C.K. Stead 'My Name Was Judas'




Stead's book was published in 2006. I haven't read it but will borrow it on OVERDRIVE and read it alongside the podcast if I find it. I like Stead's writing (Smith's Dream, Talking About O'Dwyer).
I wish that this had been written in the 1960s and I'd read it then. It would have made for some very stimulating conversations in Christian Doctrine classes at Marist Brothers and St Patrick's schools.


17 comments:

  1. Sounds like a bit of light reading. When does the windows series kick off again?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well you're an idiot. That's all I'm saying.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Actually ..... I've got more to say.
    Robert you lack logic, empathy, reasonableness, open-mindedness and a sense of reality as evidenced by your clinging to ridiculous notions fed to you from the Catholic Church's pulpits and the fabricated creed that emanated from historical and inaccurately translated 'gospels'.

    Your total rejection of another view, which is what C.K. Stead presents in his excellent book shows your narrow-mindedness.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think you too would enjoy reading Stead and, in your case, gain some benefit from it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Actually TC I did find it interesting. Just kidding around.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This post is proving very popular for The Curmudgeon Ink!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Replies
    1. haven't you got an appointment at the Petone wharf?

      Delete
  8. No, they've banned jumping off. (12 comments. Well done!)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey, where are all the other posts we were promised? (13 comments now!)

    ReplyDelete
  10. While searching and reading blogs I've been on the phone (waiting) to Air NZ to try and find WHY THEY"VE BEEN FUCKING ME AROUND WITH FLIGHT CANCELLATIONS. Bastards!
    It's been more than an hour and a half (waiting). I'm getting pissed off.
    Maybe Air New Zealand, Robert and you could all go to the bloody Petone Wharf with Robert's sculpture, his archaic beliefs and your damned Stockhausen. Break a few rules and jump off.

    (13 comments).

    ReplyDelete
  11. All good now.
    Finally (after 2 hours waiting) got through to a very competent young woman (who I thanked and told her she was a star) who has fixed flight details and I'm on my way again. I'M BACK BABY. I'M BACK! (George Costanza from Seinfield).

    ReplyDelete
  12. Actually it's 17. 18 now. All those other Curmudgeons will be jealous!

    ReplyDelete

MY GOD!

Religion, what is it? I favour the last of these definitions, the ' pursuit of interest followed with great devotion.' I'm not r...